Reading to Dogs May Improve Literacy
A new review of existing research finds reading to dogs may help children’s literacy – but the quality of evidence is weak.
Photo: waldru (top) and Soloviova Liudmyla (both Shutterstock.com).
That’s the conclusion of a new paper by Sophie Hallet al (University of Lincoln). They searched the literature for studies that investigate the effects of programs in which children read to dogs, and conducted a systematic review of 48 papers.
They write, “The evidence suggests that reading to a dog may have a beneficial effect on a number of behavioural processes which contribute to a positive effect on the environment in which reading is practiced, leading to improved reading performance.”
It sounds very promising: if children read out loud to dogs, they have a captive and non-judgemental audience. Such programs are becoming increasingly popular, so it’s important to know if they really work – not least because, as very inexpensive programs, it could be a cost-effective way to improve literacy.
Reading sessions, with volunteer dogs and handlers, take place in schools, libraries, and other locations.
Reading sessions, with volunteer dogs and handlers, take place in schools, libraries, and other locations.
“I only like to read if I am in a good mood. I am usually in a good mood on Saturdays because I have a chance to read to Lucky,” is what one 10-year-old told Intermountain Therapy Animals, who have trained over 3000 canine teams since 1999.
The review highlights several ways in which canine reading programs might help. Dogs can provide social support in themselves and also increase support from other people (the social support hypothesis). People’s affiliation with nature might lead to increased engagement when reading to a dog (the biophilia hypothesis).
Other mechanisms may include reduced anxiety, increased confidence and more motivation.
Other mechanisms may include reduced anxiety, increased confidence and more motivation.
The scientists classified the research according to established guidelines (called PRISMA). They were inclusive in identifying papers to include, and much of it was not of good quality. Some of the problems they identified were small sample sizes, lack of a control group, not enough information about the children who took part (e.g. if they are normally developing), failure to use standardized tests to assess reading ability, and not saying how long the reading intervention lasted.
So what kind of research is needed? The authors say there is a particular need for randomized controlled trials. These are the ‘gold standard’ for knowing if an intervention works or not. They only identified one for their review, which found accuracy and reading comprehension were better in children who read to a dog rather than a teddy bear or adult, or a control group that did not read to anyone.
The finding that reading to dogs appears to be helpful, but we don’t know what might cause this, is another reason for more research.
The researchers also highlight the need to take account of individual differences between children (some of whom might not like dogs, be allergic to them or frightened of them), and to find out which young readers could benefit most from such programs.
The full paper is open access via the link below, and includes a diagram outlining the different ways reading to dogs may help children.
If you are interested in volunteering your dog for a reading program, several organizations run them, including Reading Education Assistance Dogs (Intermountain Therapy Animals, international), The Bark and Read Foundation (Kennel Club, UK), Classroom Canines(Delta Society, Australia), and many others. Dogs should be friendly, up to date with vaccinations, able to sit while patted by a stranger, and take treats gently. Delta Society has a checklist to see if your dog might be a good candidate.
Reference
Hall, S., Gee, N., & Mills, D. (2016). Children Reading to Dogs: A Systematic Review of the Literature PLOS ONE, 11 (2) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0149759Photo: waldru (top) and Soloviova Liudmyla (both Shutterstock.com).
You might also like:
Do children benefit from animals in the classroom?
Does animal-assisted therapy help at-risk boys?
De-stressing with a puppy for parents of children with autism
Do children benefit from animals in the classroom?
Does animal-assisted therapy help at-risk boys?
De-stressing with a puppy for parents of children with autism
Companion Animal Psychology is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
